Five years on from Freedom and Choice, non-advised savers over 50 are facing a ticking time bomb at retirement, according to a survey by Legal & General Investment Management (LGIM) and NMG Consulting (NMG). 66% of those saving into a defined contribution (DC) pension and 58% of those who have already retired have either no firm plans or no plans at all for their retirement finances.
This has translated into considerable concern, with 57% of savers and a third of retirees fearful about their financial situation in retirement.
Non-advised savers are also less clued up than their retired peers and more likely to say that their financial situation has been negatively impacted by COVID-19, which was their top financial worry. 57% expressed concerns due to the pandemic, compared to just 41% of those who had already given up work. More than a third (35%) of prospective drawdown users admit they know nothing about the funds they are invested in, and another third is unsure.
The 25% tax-free lump sum remains the most well-known and appealing feature of DC pensions. 42% of existing drawdown users have already accessed their pot to take advantage of this, whilst 39% of those who have not yet retired expect to withdraw their tax-free cash and leave the rest of their pot invested. Ensuring this benefit stays will be crucial for future retirees. And for squeezed savers, phasing these withdrawals could ensure they don’t take out too much, too soon.
Meanwhile, a low risk tolerance and reluctance to engage informed the desire of 56% of those who had used a default fund during the accumulation journey to stay in the same product during decumulation. Therefore, defaults need to be suitable – and flexible for members’ needs.
When asked about whether they saw a need for financial advice, 41% of prospective and 35% of existing users of drawdown were put off by the idea of having to pay a fee, while one in five (20%) say they mistrust advisers.
Automated online guidance tools also faced scepticism. Four in five existing drawdown consumers are cynical about the objectivity of online calculators from pension providers. However, provider websites are the most used information source for both prospective (53%) and existing drawdown users (34%).
Leading on the research, Jane Craig, Partner for NMG Consulting commented: “Our research highlights that a lifetime of low engagement with pensions hits hard at the time when pensions really matter – at the point of making retirement income decisions. Consumers lack knowledge and show over-stated confidence in their abilities to make good decisions and this is likely to have consequences on their outcomes in retirement for many years.”
Solving non-advised savers’ decumulation dilemmas today could mean a brighter future for ‘Generation DC’.
In light of these statistics, LGIM has developed two retirement journeys for its non-advised contract, own trust and sole governance Mastertrust members. Both of LGIM’s investment pathways give members the ability to choose and switch across four different options to fulfil their requirements at different stages of retirement, and one of the journeys has an additional emphasis on ESG factors.
These pathways fit well with the asset allocation within L&G default funds, thus providing a consistent approach for members as they move to and through retirement and minimising transaction costs.
Emma Douglas, Head of Defined Contribution at LGIM: "Generation X could be the ‘canary in the coalmine’ when it comes to the long-term changes taking place in UK pensions. Pension freedoms are already approaching their five-year anniversary, but the long-term consequences are just starting to come through.
As DC pension pots grow, the decisions made by individuals as they near their retirement could have significant consequences for their finances and standard of living. Increasingly a ‘good member outcome’ is not only about helping members to build up as much as possible in their pot in the accumulation phase, but also about giving them the right options and help when it comes to spending this money. The FCA Investment Pathways and the PLSA’s work on decumulation are both steps in the right direction and we’ll see more developments along these lines as more members approach retirement relying increasingly on their DC pension to provide them with the income they need."
Notes to editors
Established in 1836, Legal & General is one of the UK’s leading financial services groups and a major global investor, with international businesses in the US, Europe, Middle East and Asia. With almost £1.3 trillion in total assets under management*, we are the UK’s largest investment manager for corporate pension schemes and a UK market leader in pension risk transfer, alternative asset origination, life insurance, workplace pensions and retirement income. Through inclusive capitalism, we aim to build a better society by investing in long-term assets that benefit everyone.
* at 30 June 2021